Atlantis: a grain of truth behind the fiction?
Appendix
Versione italiana

Previous page

    Both Plato and Diodorus gave geographical indications regarding the location of Atlantis.

    Since Plato’s indications were not relevant to his propaganda issues, one could imagine that the geographical details of the dialogues maintained some unmodified elements of the original Egyptian myth. Questionable as this is, a summary of Plato’s main clues is reported below.

    Nine thousand years before the visit of Solon to Sais (Tim. III 23.e; Crit. III 108.e), the Atlantic Sea [A1] was navigable (Crit. III 109.a) and, in front of the Pillars of Hercules (Tim. III 24.e), was an island larger than Libya and Asia combined. This island was close to other islands and, by ‘hopping’ between them, one could reach the continent that enclosed the vast ocean. The ‘capital’ of this empire was a small island which ruled over the entire archipelago. On the continent, Atlantis ruled Europe up to Thyrrenia and Libya (Africa) from the Pillars to the Egyptian border (Tim. III 25.b). The main island of the archipelago had a large plain, three thousand stadia (approximately, 550 km) long and two thousand stadia (350 km) wide, [A2] surrounded by northern mountains and by a southern channel that ended in the open sea (Crit. X 118.b), with rivers, lakes, mountains and marshes, two harvests per year (Crit. X 118.e), elephants (Crit. VI 114.e) and exotic fruits (Crit. VI 115.b). Its first king was Atlas (Crit. VI 114.b), who ran the country perfectly, following commendable political principles, second only to those of Athens. But when Atlantis wanted to conquer Egypt and Athens, the heroic Athenians resisted and defeated it, freeing Egypt, which in the meantime had been subjugated, as well. A little later, a violent earthquake and a flood destroyed Atlantis in a day and a night, leaving an impenetrable swamp in place of the island (Tim. III 26.d); Athens also perished in the cataclysm.


Figure A1. The locations the Atlanteans, according to Diodorus. Map from NOAA site.[A5]

    Diodorus too provided some geographical hints about Atlantis. According to him many generations before the Trojan War, the refined Atlanteans were subjugated by the Libyan Amazons (Book III, 54, 1). In fact, long before the Amazons of classical tradition (who lived along the river Thermodon, on the southern coast of the Black Sea – author’s note), Libya was inhabited by other Amazons originating from an island on Lake Tritonis [A3] (Book III, 53, 4), from which they dominated the surrounding region (Figure A1). [A4]

    The Atlanteans surrendered en masse to the Amazon queen Myrina when Cernę, the only city of theirs that had tried to resist, was completely destroyed (Book III, 54, 5). According to Diodorus, the Atlanteans, who had many cities and lived in a fertile region on the coast (Book III, 56, 2), were an extremely refined and pious people, because the gods had been born among them. Their first king had been Uranus, a god who had elevated them from their bestial state and taught them agriculture (Book III, 56, 3).

    Uranus had several wives, including Titea, later called Gaea, who bore him eighteen children: the Titans. One of these, Hyperion, succeeded his father and, on his death, the kingdom was divided between his brother Kronos and his nephew Atlas (son of another brother, Iapetus). Atlas took the coastal and the mountainous regions, giving his name not only to the mountains, but also to the inhabitants of the whole kingdom (Book III, 60, 1). According to the Cretans, Kronos reigned over Sicily, Libya and Italy (Book III, 60, 3).

References



[A1] Plato uses the term Atlantic Sea indistinguishably for an enclosed sea near the island-capital (no longer delimited in Plato’s times due to the sinking of the islands that used to surround it and no longer navigable due to the presence of marshes and shallow waters) and for a large open sea, surrounded by the continent dominated by Atlantis.

[A2] The dimensions of the plain of Atlantis are not those of a continent, in contradiction of the statement “Libya and Asia combined”, whose size Plato was certainly aware of. To this extent one point should be clear: twelve thousand years ago (or even at the glacial maximum) in no part of the world was there an emerged seabed the size of a continent. The bottom of the Atlantic Ocean is thousands of metres deep and no portion of it ever emerged following a drop in sea level of just 120 metres. From a geological point of view, twelve thousand years is a pittance, ten thousand times shorter than the movements of continental plates. Those invoking the continental drift demand movements occurring over tens or hundreds of millions of years, not thousands of years: days when humans simply did not exist.

[A3] Identifiable with the vast Saharan depression south of the Atlas Mountains, which was actually a lake several thousand years ago.

[A4] The source, quoted by Diodorus, is Dionysius, almost certainly Scytobrachion, a Mytilene mythographer who lived and taught in Alexandria in the second century BC.

[A5] http://maps.ngdc.noaa.gov/viewers/wcs-client/


Posted July 10th, 2018; last modified July 10th, 2018.

Since 2018 this site has been accessed times;
Atlantis has been visited times.